Page 6 of 9

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Wed Jul 22, 2015 5:14 pm
by Gnosis
Exactly. Radically different from those warscrolls with their myriad special rules in that you have all your faction's idiosyncrasies laid out on a single A4 before you as a game piece. Superbly elegant, that.

As far as fantasy skirmish wargaming goes I'm also interested in Frostgrave, just released by Osprey and North Star:http://nstarmagazine.com/FROSTGRAVE.htm

If the rules are well-construed then it might become a worthy successor to Mordheim; I'll probably pick up the rules and play with my WHFB models, maybe an Empire wizard or two plus some free company fighters.

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Thu Jul 23, 2015 1:00 am
by Arquinsiel
I flicked through the book earlier today. It seems somewhat like warmahordes in that you get to pick a commander type, and then the other models are basically the same for every warband. It is, really, about a Wizard who goes searching for power and has some random hired mooks and maybe an apprentice along for the ride.

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Thu Jul 23, 2015 11:33 am
by Gnosis
That's what I gathered from the (usually positive) reviews on the web. I just hope it has a better balanced campaign system than Mordheim had. I ordered two of the books, my mate will be using his Bretonnians and I'll likely be using Perry Miniatures Italian renaissance models with Empire wizards. Flinging d20s will be excellent ;)

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Thu Jul 23, 2015 12:33 pm
by Eldarwonderland
Playing my second game of Kings of War on Weds 29 July.

I originally thought it was an "any port in a storm" game. However it has some good points, granted we can't use ALL our models from WHFB but many are directly ported over or can be substituted easily.

Give it a go.
Full Rulebook + all army rosters for £10.

Yes AoS is free but you'll spend more than £10 on indigestion and ulcer tablets if you suffer the angst of playing or even thinking about the new primary school age game from Gee DubYah.

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Thu Jul 23, 2015 8:08 pm
by Red...
Yes AoS is free but...
...it'll cost you your soul ;)

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Thu Jul 23, 2015 8:51 pm
by Amboadine
Red... wrote:
Yes AoS is free but...
...it'll cost you your soul ;)



:D nice

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Thu Jul 23, 2015 8:55 pm
by Arquinsiel
Gnosis wrote:That's what I gathered from the (usually positive) reviews on the web. I just hope it has a better balanced campaign system than Mordheim had. I ordered two of the books, my mate will be using his Bretonnians and I'll likely be using Perry Miniatures Italian renaissance models with Empire wizards. Flinging d20s will be excellent ;)

I actually didn't spot the D20s somehow, but it was a really quick flickthrough. I may give it a pass then, since Infinity has put me off the idea of a D20 skirmish game.

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Thu Jul 23, 2015 9:33 pm
by Killerk
d20 is amazing, the more value of the die the better the game is. in d6 the jumps are by 16% in a d20 you have 5%, it makes for a much better game, as the game is much much much less dicey. Example, to get 50%+ on a d6 you can score 4,5,6 only 3 results per dice roll, on a d20 its 10 possible results. It makes a world of a difference, it also allows for much better game mechanics.

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Thu Jul 23, 2015 11:06 pm
by toots
My dice fly off the table all too frequently as it is, D20s are practically spherical though - there's no stopping them!!!

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Thu Jul 23, 2015 11:15 pm
by Arquinsiel
Killerk wrote:d20 is amazing, the more value of the die the better the game is. in d6 the jumps are by 16% in a d20 you have 5%, it makes for a much better game, as the game is much much much less dicey. Example, to get 50%+ on a d6 you can score 4,5,6 only 3 results per dice roll, on a d20 its 10 possible results. It makes a world of a difference, it also allows for much better game mechanics.
I very much disagree with that, I find the game is far MORE dicey, in that the results are able to swing to a ridiculous degree. In an RPG that's fine, but in a skirmish wargame it leads to bad things happening. Far better to use multiple identical dice and get a bell curve.

Also your maths example is silly. The more results just mean there are more irrelevant subdivisions of a coinflip.

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Sat Jul 25, 2015 4:49 am
by cultofkhaine
Looks like 40k to me.

Image

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Sat Jul 25, 2015 7:54 am
by Amboadine
Wow. That's not even trying to hide the 40k influence.
Hoping that the Aelves are a little more to my liking when they arrive.

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Sat Jul 25, 2015 7:57 am
by anthalont
Is that supposed to be a crossbow? :O

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Sat Jul 25, 2015 9:22 am
by cultofkhaine
Yep and the archers look like boltthrowers lol

$85 for five models looks rather steep as well http://www.games-workshop.com/en-AU/Stormcast-Eternals-Judicators

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Sat Jul 25, 2015 10:26 am
by Draecarion
Haha, that crossbow is ridiculous !lol!
No way I will use that monstrostiy, no matter how strong it is :roll:

$85 for five models looks rather steep as well http://www.games-workshop.com/en-AU/Sto ... Judicators


Not more expensive than 5 terminators (and they are of similar scale and equipment options). You don't need that many Stormcast Eternals for an army anyway (at least at the moment).

Hoping that the Aelves are a little more to my liking when they arrive.


I'm also really curious. My local store manager said, after he had visited Nottingham, that the new Aelf stuff he saw looked pretty amazing. And much more elf-like, so more fragile, lithe and lethal. We will see. I bought the Stormcast Eternals from the starter set (split the box with a friend who took the chaos stuff), but I don't think I will continue collecting them for now and save my money for Aelfs and terrain (which looks pretty sweet so far). The Stormcast Eternals are just a "little" too hamfisted for my taste. I mean quite literally, their fists and their legs, everything looks a bit clumsy.

Re: First game of AoS, DE vs Warriors of Chaos

Posted: Sat Jul 25, 2015 12:32 pm
by Dalamar
From all the reports I've read so far it looks like AoS is an expensive card game with miniatures instead of cards.

You build your "deck" based on synergies and then make them work in game. Difference being you start with all your "cards" available to you and don't need to count on luck of the draw.

If I wanted to play card games I'd play Hearthstone (which I do)

Re: First game of AoS, DE vs Warriors of Chaos

Posted: Sat Jul 25, 2015 4:17 pm
by Killerk
Iąm sorry but there is no tactical any thing in this game, you just push everything forward.... but you don't really need to do that as who ever has more elite models wins. I didn't want to write this earlier, as you took time to make this report, but all the AoS reports I read so far sound the same:
We pushed forward I lost there but rolled well and won there, in the end ... won the game. There is strategy in every game, but AoS destroyed that with deployment rules.

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Sun Jul 26, 2015 6:52 am
by Saintofm
Howdy all, long time no see.

I might have to agree with the GW phasing out Warhammer all together theory. The fantasy section of the black library is more bare then a politician's conscience. This means they cleared out mainstays like Malus and everyone's favorite berserker with a shotman's complex.

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Sun Jul 26, 2015 4:17 pm
by taggart
Not that impressed with what i've seen or read so far . my bug bear is the price of the new models .
£30 sterling for 5 ! Mind you they will sell you 2 boxes for £60 !!! ?
Is there going to be a day when GW stop selling the , now , old fantasy stuff ?

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Sun Jul 26, 2015 9:00 pm
by Saintofm
taggart wrote:Not that impressed with what i've seen or read so far . my bug bear is the price of the new models .
£30 sterling for 5 ! Mind you they will sell you 2 boxes for £60 !!! ?
Is there going to be a day when GW stop selling the , now , old fantasy stuff ?



Yep, for the new and improved "we sware we are not space marines" that look like extras from Chrinicles of Riddick

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Sun Aug 02, 2015 3:21 pm
by cultofkhaine
A few people were thinking the release of the new game might be the death of fantasy in disguise - I think it might be around for a little while longer.

Image

more photos here... http://www.spikeybits.com/2015/07/out-with-the-astartes-in-with-the-stormcast.html

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Sun Aug 02, 2015 11:39 pm
by Duffman327
Fantasy won't really go anywhere, in spirit that is. if AOS does stay around, then we know that the new releases are going to be fantastic looking minis. As much as them looking 40Kish they are still nice looking models. Im a big fan of the khorne minis personally.

But i have a feeling that AOS may be a stepping stone to new revamped Fantasy Game. it may take 10 years to get there but if they can make fantasy as popular as 40K then they are on to a winner.

I find the game system mechanics rather quick and fun. very simple "just get on with it" type game.

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:29 am
by Red...
Kings of War had quite an amusing response to the Age of Sigmar silly mega statue...

Image

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Tue Aug 04, 2015 12:08 am
by Arquinsiel
Cultofkhaine wrote:A few people were thinking the release of the new game might be the death of fantasy in disguise - I think it might be around for a little while longer.

Image

more photos here... http://www.spikeybits.com/2015/07/out-with-the-astartes-in-with-the-stormcast.html
I dunno, this might be a sign of backing the wrong horse in the next race too, because he's gotta win sometime right?

Re: Un-Welcome to the Age of Sigmar

Posted: Tue Aug 04, 2015 5:19 pm
by Gnosis
I'm seeing plenty of people on numerous message boards, for example Daeron on our beloved d.net, putting lots of time and effort into theorising various aspects of the new AoS ruleset, with various mathematical breakdowns and the like. There also seem to be lots of debates on the tactical side of it, chiefly on maximising pile in moves and optimal initial deployment. Lots of cogent debates going up and down the web, it seems.

My question may be blunt, but: Why the bloody hell would you put that much effort into it?

AoS is a ridiculously barebones ruleset with all of the original WHFB-flavoured warscrolls being a hasty afterthought (or afterbirth?), badly-worded core game mechanics and plenty of generally wonky situations. Before you hit the 'quote' button: yes, this is merely my opinion and you may disagree. So forgive me if I'm wrong about this, but I'm thinking: is it worth putting your effort into dissecting this ruleset? Because:

1) It's (hopefully) still in development and bound to change, even quite drastically, so all the theorising might be undone at GW's whim;
2) And of course, being the cynical bastard I am: Why would you bother putting that much effort into a ruleset that was obviously created over the course of an afternoon? Is it worth gracing such a ruleset with that much of your time? I realise I'm being blunt here, but I just can't see the angle.